Mystic Pizza NYC Tickets

Mystic Pizza
Venue: Paper Mill Playhouse

Don’t miss Mystic Pizza in NYC. These mesmerizing shows will leave you breathless and provide great memories for years. “NYC Events” provides guaranteed Broadway tickets at the best prices. Get Mystic Pizza tickets today! The next show begins in…

--
Days
--
Hours
--
Minutes
--
Seconds

Contents
NYC Schedule & Tickets
Mystic Pizza Touring
Mystic Pizza Ticket Prices
Mystic Pizza

Now Playing & Upcoming Shows 2024/2025

Reset
Cancel
Apply
Shows: 36
  • Jan
    29
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Wed
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $60
    Avg. price ~ $135
    Available Tickets: 220
    Tickets
  • Jan
    30
    2025
    1:30 PM
    Thu
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $105
    Avg. price ~ $269
    Available Tickets: 72
    Tickets
  • Jan
    30
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Thu
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $60
    Avg. price ~ $136
    Available Tickets: 222
    Tickets
  • Jan
    31
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Fri
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $74
    Avg. price ~ $157
    Available Tickets: 268
    Tickets
  • Feb
    01
    2025
    1:30 PM
    Sat
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $74
    Avg. price ~ $158
    Available Tickets: 207
    Tickets
  • Feb
    01
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Sat
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $74
    Avg. price ~ $155
    Available Tickets: 207
    Tickets
  • Feb
    02
    2025
    1:30 PM
    Sun
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $74
    Avg. price ~ $174
    Available Tickets: 135
    Tickets
  • Feb
    02
    2025
    7:00 PM
    Sun
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $60
    Avg. price ~ $189
    Available Tickets: 130
    Tickets
  • Feb
    05
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Wed
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $60
    Avg. price ~ $126
    Available Tickets: 169
    Tickets
  • Feb
    06
    2025
    1:30 PM
    Thu
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $105
    Avg. price ~ $372
    41 tickets remaining!
    Tickets
  • Feb
    06
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Thu
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $60
    Avg. price ~ $195
    Available Tickets: 90
    Tickets
  • Feb
    07
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Fri
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $74
    Avg. price ~ $154
    Available Tickets: 225
    Tickets
  • Feb
    08
    2025
    1:30 PM
    Sat
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $74
    Avg. price ~ $152
    Available Tickets: 196
    Tickets
  • Feb
    08
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Sat
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $74
    Avg. price ~ $158
    Available Tickets: 129
    Tickets
  • Feb
    09
    2025
    1:30 PM
    Sun
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $74
    Avg. price ~ $163
    Available Tickets: 152
    Tickets
  • Feb
    09
    2025
    7:00 PM
    Sun
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $60
    Avg. price ~ $155
    Available Tickets: 193
    Tickets
  • Feb
    12
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Wed
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $60
    Avg. price ~ $130
    Available Tickets: 226
    Tickets
  • Feb
    13
    2025
    1:30 PM
    Thu
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $105
    Avg. price ~ $236
    Available Tickets: 116
    Tickets
  • Feb
    13
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Thu
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $60
    Avg. price ~ $131
    Available Tickets: 190
    Tickets
  • Feb
    14
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Fri
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $74
    Avg. price ~ $156
    Available Tickets: 258
    Tickets
  • Feb
    15
    2025
    1:30 PM
    Sat
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $73
    Avg. price ~ $156
    Available Tickets: 252
    Tickets
  • Feb
    15
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Sat
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $73
    Avg. price ~ $150
    Available Tickets: 242
    Tickets
  • Feb
    16
    2025
    1:30 PM
    Sun
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $73
    Avg. price ~ $167
    Available Tickets: 169
    Tickets
  • Feb
    16
    2025
    7:00 PM
    Sun
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $60
    Avg. price ~ $159
    Available Tickets: 184
    Tickets
  • Feb
    19
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Wed
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $60
    Avg. price ~ $137
    Available Tickets: 312
    Tickets
  • Feb
    20
    2025
    1:30 PM
    Thu
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $105
    Avg. price ~ $348
    36 tickets remaining!
    Tickets
  • Feb
    20
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Thu
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $60
    Avg. price ~ $135
    Available Tickets: 266
    Tickets
  • Feb
    21
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Fri
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $73
    Avg. price ~ $154
    Available Tickets: 300
    Tickets
  • Feb
    22
    2025
    1:30 PM
    Sat
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $73
    Avg. price ~ $151
    Available Tickets: 237
    Tickets
  • Feb
    22
    2025
    7:30 PM
    Sat
    Mystic Pizza
    Paper Mill Playhouse
    07041, 22 Brookside Drive, Millburn, NJ, US
    Prices from $74
    Avg. price ~ $164
    Available Tickets: 263
    Tickets
Show More

Mystic Pizza is Also Touring To:

Mystic Pizza Tampa
Tampa, FL
location Carol Morsani Hall - The Straz Center
Apr 29, 2025
Tue   7:30 PM
Mystic Pizza West Palm Beach
West Palm Beach, FL
location Kravis Center - Dreyfoos Concert Hall
May 13, 2025
Tue   7:30 PM
Mystic Pizza Saint Paul
Saint Paul, MN
location Ordway Music Theater at Ordway Center For Performing Arts
Jun 03, 2025
Tue   7:30 PM
Mystic Pizza Colorado Springs
Colorado Springs, CO
location Pikes Peak Center
Jun 10, 2025
Tue   7:30 PM
Mystic Pizza Lincoln
Lincoln, NE
location Lied Center For Performing Arts
Jun 14, 2025
Sat   2:00 PM
Mystic Pizza Waterbury
Waterbury, CT
location Palace Theater - CT
Jun 20, 2025
Fri   8:00 PM

Mystic Pizza Ticket Prices

Date Venue Min price Max price Avg. price Available Tickets
Jan 29, 2025
Wed 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $427 $135 220
Jan 30, 2025
Thu 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$105 $491 $269 72
Jan 30, 2025
Thu 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $427 $136 222
Jan 31, 2025
Fri 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$74 $427 $157 268
Feb 01, 2025
Sat 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$74 $427 $158 207
Feb 01, 2025
Sat 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$74 $427 $155 207
Feb 02, 2025
Sun 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$74 $427 $174 135
Feb 02, 2025
Sun 7:00 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $491 $189 130
Feb 05, 2025
Wed 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $427 $126 169
Feb 06, 2025
Thu 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$105 $491 $372 41
Feb 06, 2025
Thu 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $491 $195 90
Feb 07, 2025
Fri 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$74 $427 $154 225
Feb 08, 2025
Sat 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$74 $427 $152 196
Feb 08, 2025
Sat 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$74 $427 $158 129
Feb 09, 2025
Sun 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$74 $491 $163 152
Feb 09, 2025
Sun 7:00 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $491 $155 193
Feb 12, 2025
Wed 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $427 $130 226
Feb 13, 2025
Thu 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$105 $482 $236 116
Feb 13, 2025
Thu 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $427 $131 190
Feb 14, 2025
Fri 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$74 $427 $156 258
Feb 15, 2025
Sat 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$73 $427 $156 252
Feb 15, 2025
Sat 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$73 $427 $150 242
Feb 16, 2025
Sun 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$73 $482 $167 169
Feb 16, 2025
Sun 7:00 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $482 $159 184
Feb 19, 2025
Wed 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $427 $137 312
Feb 20, 2025
Thu 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$105 $482 $348 36
Feb 20, 2025
Thu 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $427 $135 266
Feb 21, 2025
Fri 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$73 $427 $154 300
Feb 22, 2025
Sat 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$73 $427 $151 237
Feb 22, 2025
Sat 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$74 $500 $164 263
Feb 23, 2025
Sun 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$73 $427 $148 211
Feb 23, 2025
Sun 7:00 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$60 $427 $133 251
Feb 26, 2025
Wed 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$105 $500 $354 49
Feb 27, 2025
Thu 1:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$105 $500 $373 41
Feb 27, 2025
Thu 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$105 $500 $373 41
Feb 28, 2025
Fri 7:30 PM 		Paper Mill Playhouse,
Millburn, NJ 		$105 $500 $373 41
Apr 29, 2025
Tue 7:30 PM 		Carol Morsani Hall - The Straz Center,
Tampa, FL 		$103 $678 $237 38
Apr 30, 2025
Wed 7:30 PM 		Carol Morsani Hall - The Straz Center,
Tampa, FL 		$103 $678 $256 40
May 01, 2025
Thu 7:30 PM 		Carol Morsani Hall - The Straz Center,
Tampa, FL 		$103 $678 $234 44
May 02, 2025
Fri 8:00 PM 		Carol Morsani Hall - The Straz Center,
Tampa, FL 		$103 $678 $241 44
May 03, 2025
Sat 2:00 PM 		Carol Morsani Hall - The Straz Center,
Tampa, FL 		$73 $678 $195 46
May 03, 2025
Sat 8:00 PM 		Carol Morsani Hall - The Straz Center,
Tampa, FL 		$73 $678 $202 44
May 04, 2025
Sun 1:00 PM 		Carol Morsani Hall - The Straz Center,
Tampa, FL 		$103 $678 $207 44
May 04, 2025
Sun 7:00 PM 		Carol Morsani Hall - The Straz Center,
Tampa, FL 		$103 $678 $213 40
May 13, 2025
Tue 7:30 PM 		Kravis Center - Dreyfoos Concert Hall,
West Palm Beach, FL 		$96 $660 $142 38
May 14, 2025
Wed 2:00 PM 		Kravis Center - Dreyfoos Concert Hall,
West Palm Beach, FL 		$96 $660 $142 40
May 14, 2025
Wed 7:30 PM 		Kravis Center - Dreyfoos Concert Hall,
West Palm Beach, FL 		$96 $660 $141 32
May 15, 2025
Thu 7:30 PM 		Kravis Center - Dreyfoos Concert Hall,
West Palm Beach, FL 		$96 $660 $141 32
May 16, 2025
Fri 8:00 PM 		Kravis Center - Dreyfoos Concert Hall,
West Palm Beach, FL 		$85 $660 $149 45
May 17, 2025
Sat 2:00 PM 		Kravis Center - Dreyfoos Concert Hall,
West Palm Beach, FL 		$91 $660 $150 64

All Theater Shows in NYC

Radio City Rockettes
Radio City Rockettes
Shows: 198
Radio City Music Hall
Nov 8, 2024 2:00 PM
Radio City Christmas Spectacular
Radio City Christmas Spectacular
Shows: 198
Radio City Music Hall
Nov 8, 2024 2:00 PM
Blue Man Group
Blue Man Group
Shows: 233
Blue Man Theater at The Luxor Hotel
Nov 8, 2024 5:00 PM
Sweat - The Play
Sweat - The Play
Shows: 6
Kupferberg Center for the Arts - Colden Auditorium
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
The Outsiders
The Outsiders
Shows: 276
Bernard B. Jacobs Theater
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Long Island Nets
Long Island Nets
Shows: 20
Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Jeff Arcuri
Jeff Arcuri
Shows: 4
Beacon Theatre - NY
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Moulin Rouge - The Musical
Moulin Rouge - The Musical
Shows: 230
Al Hirschfeld Theatre
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
The Book Of Mormon
The Book Of Mormon
Shows: 112
Eugene O'Neill Theatre
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
The Play That Goes Wrong
The Play That Goes Wrong
Shows: 236
New World Stages: Stage 4
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Hamilton
Hamilton
Shows: 209
Richard Rodgers Theatre
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Big Apple Circus
Big Apple Circus
Shows: 77
Damrosch Park At Lincoln Center
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Harry Potter and The Cursed Child
Harry Potter and The Cursed Child
Shows: 227
Lyric Theatre - New York
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Ms. Pat
Ms. Pat
Shows: 1
Town Hall Theatre - NY
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Yellow Face
Yellow Face
Shows: 21
Todd Haimes Theatre
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Romeo and Juliet - Theatrical Production
Romeo and Juliet - Theatrical Production
Shows: 116
Circle In The Square Theatre
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
The Gazillion Bubble Show
The Gazillion Bubble Show
Shows: 215
New World Stages: Stage 2
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Hadestown
Hadestown
Shows: 194
Walter Kerr Theatre
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
King Lear
King Lear
Shows: 24
Griffin Theater at The Shed
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
New York Comedy Festival
New York Comedy Festival
Shows: 29
Beacon Theatre - NY
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Maine Celtics
Maine Celtics
Shows: 4
Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Once Upon a Mattress
Once Upon a Mattress
Shows: 28
Millennium Hudson Theatre
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Sommore
Sommore
Shows: 1
The Venue at Hard Rock Hotel New York
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
The Great Gatsby - Theatrical Production
The Great Gatsby - Theatrical Production
Shows: 173
Broadway Theatre - New York
Nov 8, 2024 7:00 PM
Show More